The backlash about data centers might really just be about electricity

2026-11-16 · MIT Technology Review

The Backlash About Data Centers Might Really Just Be About Electricity

As voters went to the polls across the US, the author visited Ashburn, Virginia, part of "Data Center Alley"—the world’s largest data center hub and the place where the current backlash against data centers arguably first began.

Big Tech's "Culture War" Narrative

It is accepted wisdom in Big Tech that the war against data centers must be about something bigger. Chris Lehane, OpenAI’s chief global affairs officer, wrote that data centers "have become a proxy for public unease about affordability, corporate power, and people losing control over their futures." In other words, it is framed as a culture war.

The True Core of the Backlash: Electricity

However, spending time in Data Center Alley convinced the author that the backlash is more about electricity than Big Tech admits. The industry cannot escape the physical consequences of its enormous appetite for power.

  • The Burden on the Grid: In Virginia’s Loudoun County, most data centers connect to the existing grid. For instance, an Equinix facility gets its power from Dominion Energy, largely generated by natural gas. The average data center here has a power capacity of 54 megawatts, exceeding the draw of the Denver International Airport.
  • Protests and New Rules: Activist Elena Schlossberg emphasizes that the fight was "always about power." The particular consequences of drawing so much power have led Virginia to enact new rules requiring data centers to pay fully for new transmission lines. Developers are also preparing for rules that might cut them off during peak demand. Furthermore, there are concerns that a strained grid will lead to more diesel generator usage or expanded fossil fuel inputs.

Onsite Power Generation in Rural Areas

The majority of new AI data centers elsewhere are built in rural areas with virtually no grid infrastructure, requiring companies to generate their own power ("behind the meter").

  • Gas and Diesel Generators: Companies build natural-gas-powered turbines and diesel generators for backup. Anthropic, for example, has reportedly agreed to pay $3.4 billion for gas turbines, the largest power generation purchase by an AI company.
  • Massive Scale: The smallest AI data centers draw 300 megawatts, while ideal facilities reach 6,000 megawatts—equivalent to the city of Chicago, which is powered by over 20 power plants.
  • Environmental Pollution: While bringing their own power might seem to spare the grid, generating electricity at this scale inevitably affects communities. Natural-gas turbines release air pollutants, and diesel generators are worse. In the rush to operate, companies have become horrible neighbors; Elon Musk, for instance, violated air quality laws by setting up dozens of turbines in Memphis.

Conclusion: The Inescapable Physical Reality

Big Tech’s tendency to chalk the backlash up to a culture war obfuscates a simple fact: there’s only so pleasant you can make a small city of computers to live around. While companies can pursue better deals, hire locally, and increase community involvement, asking a small town to welcome a facility comparable to an international airport, a steel plant, and the power plants to run them is bound to cause trepidation.

This is not to say electricity is the sole reason for opposition. Fears of job losses, existential risks, concentrated corporate power, and misinformation also fuel the backlash. Nor is consuming enormous amounts of electricity inherently bad. However, the physical consequences of massive electricity consumption remain the central issue driving the backlash.

Source